Free AI visibility check

Competitor AI share analysis

What Is Competitor AI Share Analysis, and Who Is AI Recommending Instead of You?

The short answer

Competitor AI share analysis measures how often AI assistants name your brand compared with competing insurers when buyers ask category questions such as “What is the best term life insurance for a 40-year-old?” It shows your share of AI answers, which competitors win the answers you lose, for which questions, and which sources the AI cites for them. Marketing teams use it to set priorities and to justify budget with a clear competitive benchmark.

By · Updated · 3 min read

Why share of AI answers is the new share of voice

A search results page lists ten links. An AI answer names a handful of brands, and for many buyers that answer is the whole shortlist.

Pew Research Center found that people click a link inside Google's AI summary in only 1% of visits, and Ahrefs measured about 58% fewer clicks to the top-ranking page when an AI Overview appears. If a competitor is named in the answer and you are not, ranking well below it does little. AI share of voice measures the part of the market you can actually be seen in.

What competitor AI share analysis shows

Metrics in the analysis
Metric What it shows
Share of AI answersHow often you are named, against each competitor
Recommendation shareHow often each brand is recommended, not just listed
First-mention rateHow often each brand is named first
Share by engineWhere you are strong or weak: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Google AI Overviews
Share by question themeWhich topics each competitor owns, such as no-exam policies, seniors or health conditions
Source gapWebsites the AI cites for competitors but not for you
Description comparisonHow AI describes each brand's strengths and weaknesses

Example of a competitor AI share report

Illustrative example data only

Illustrative results
Brand Share of AI answers Recommended Named first
Competitor A64%41%33%
Competitor B48%30%21%
Your brand22%9%4%
Competitor C19%11%6%

In this example, the gap to Competitor A is largest on questions about no-exam policies, and three of the five most-cited sources for that theme never mention your brand. That tells you where to act first.

How we calculate share of AI answers

Share of AI answers = answers that name your brand ÷ all answers collected for the same questions.

We build a question set grouped by theme (term life, whole life, no-exam, seniors, health conditions and, for agencies, local questions), run it across every major engine from your market, repeat each run three times because AI answers vary, and score every answer the same way each month.

You choose the competitors; we suggest any that appear often but are missing from your list.

How to use the results

  1. Pick the themes to win. Focus on question themes where a competitor dominates and your products are a strong fit.
  2. Close the source gap. Get your brand onto the sites the AI cites for those themes, through corrections, PR and partnerships.
  3. Improve the pages AI reads. Make your product pages for those themes easy to quote. See AI search optimization for insurers.
  4. Make the budget case. A clear gap to a named competitor is the most persuasive slide in a budget request.
  5. Track monthly. Share of AI answers is tracked as part of AI visibility monitoring.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is a good share of AI answers?

There is no industry benchmark yet. What matters is your share against the competitors you lose business to, and whether the gap closes over time.

Why does ChatGPT recommend my competitor instead of us?

Usually because the competitor is cited by more independent sources, has clearer product pages or appears in the comparison articles the AI reads. The source gap in the analysis shows exactly where.

Can we choose which competitors are analyzed?

Yes. You name the competitors that matter to you, and we flag any others that appear often in AI answers.

Why does a smaller competitor beat us in AI answers?

AI rewards clarity and corroboration, not company size. A smaller insurer with plain product pages and strong third-party coverage can outperform a larger one.

How often should competitor AI share be measured?

Monthly. AI answers shift with model updates and new content, so a single snapshot goes out of date quickly.

See who AI names instead of you.

Our free AI visibility check shows which competitors appear in AI answers for the questions your buyers ask.

Run my free check